Biology, stock assessment and angler attitudes towards the introduction of slot size limits for a recreationally important species Sparodon durbanensis (Sparidae) in South Africa
- Authors: Hewett, Kyle
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Sparidae -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/48389 , vital:40855
- Description: Sparodon durbanensis (white musselcracker) is an endemic fish species in the Family Sparidae found in shallow (< 20 m) coastal waters from the Western Cape to KwaZulu-Natal. It is large-growing, late-maturing, long-lived and is a popular target species in the South African marine shore-based line and spear fisheries. Management regulations for the species have remained the same for over two decades despite anecdotal information of population declines. However, since the last life history-information for S. durbanensis was collected in the late 1980s, there is a paucity of contemporary information needed to inform wise management. The aim of this study was to collect contemporary socio-ecological information on the species and its fishery in order to better inform the management of the species. In order to do this, the growth-rate of historical and contemporary samples of Sparodon durbanensis was compared, a length-based stock assessment was performed and the knowledge and attitudes of anglers towards the introduction of improved regulations were investigated. The growth-rate was compared using otolith width as a proxy for fish growth. It was found that the growth-rate had remained relatively stable between 1963 and 2010, suggesting that S. durbanensis may be resilient to the increasing levels of environmental variability observed throughout its range and that the historical growth parameters determined for this species may remain applicable for contemporary stock assessment. The batch fecundity was determined for 50 mm size classes and used to estimate the percentage cumulative population batch fecundity using historical 803 mm FL (904 mm TL) and contemporary 776 mm FL (874 mm TL) length structure, respectively. Based on these observations a suitable harvest slot limit of 600-850 mm TL was suggested. A Length-Based Spawning Potential Ratio (SPR) model was used to provide the first formal stock assessment for S. durbanensis. The input parameters of M/k=1.44, L∞=1021 mm FL, L50=350 mm FL and L95=800 mm FL and length composition data comprising of 134 lengths obtained from a collection of competitive angling catches, estimated a SPR of 41%, which is above the 40% target reference point. A total of 126 online and face– to-face, replica questionnaires were completed by spearfishermen and recreational shore anglers. Responses indicated that anglers that target S. durbanensis are generally a specialized group who are knowledgeable about the biology and ecology of the species and are passionate about the conservation of the species. Participants indicated that Marine Protected Areas are likely the most effective regulation in the current suite of regulations used to manage the fishery and suggested that poor law enforcement was the major factor inhibiting the efficacy of fishery regulations. New proposed regulations, such as a harvest slot limit (and particularly the one between 600-850 mm TL) for S. durbanensis, was well supported, however participants suggested that non-compliance was a concern. Although, the SPR remained above the 40% target reference point, further declines in the stock status should be prevented through the implementation of a 600-850 mm TL harvest slot limit. Based on the findings of this study, this limit should provide protection against both growth and recruitment overfishing by providing protection to sexually immature, fast growing fish and to large adults that contribute the greatest proportion to population replenishment.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020
Movement patterns and genetic stock delineation of an endemic South African sparid, the Poenskop, Cymatoceps nasutus (Castelnau, 1861)
- Authors: Murray, Taryn Sara
- Date: 2013
- Subjects: Fish stock assessment -- South Africa , Sparidae -- South Africa , Fishes -- Reproduction -- South Africa , Fishing -- South Africa , Fish populations -- South Africa , Fishes -- Behavior -- South Africa , Marine fishes -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5178 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1001514 , Fish stock assessment -- South Africa , Sparidae -- South Africa , Fishes -- Reproduction -- South Africa , Fishing -- South Africa , Fish populations -- South Africa , Fishes -- Behavior -- South Africa , Marine fishes -- South Africa
- Description: Poenskop Cymatoceps nasutus (Pisces: Sparidae), an endemic South African sparid, is an important angling species being predominantly targeted by the recreational shore and skiboat sector. This species is slow-growing, long-lived, late-maturing and sex-changing, making poenskop acutely sensitive to over-exploitation. Despite interventions, such as the imposition of size and bag limits (currently 50 cm TL and one per licensed fisher per day) by authorities, catch-per-unit-effort trends reflect a severe and consistent stock decline over the last two decades. Poenskop has been identified as a priority species for research and conservation. Although the biology and population dynamics of this species have been well-documented, little is known about the movement behaviour of poenskop. Furthermore, there is a complete lack of information on its genetic stock structure. This thesis aimed to address the current knowledge gaps concerning movement behaviour and genetic stock structure of poenskop, making use of a range of methods and drawing on available information, including available fishery records as well as published and unpublished survey and research data, and data from long-term monitoring programmes. Analysis of available catch data (published and unpublished) revealed a decline in the number of poenskop caught as well as size of fish taken over the last two decades, ultimately reflecting the collapse of the stock (estimated to be at 20% of their pristine level). Improved catch-per-unit-effort data from the Tsitsikamma National Park Marine Protected Area (MPA), and larger poenskop being caught in the no-take areas than adjacent exploited areas of the Pondoland MPA confirmed that MPAs can be effective for the protection and management of poenskop. The current MPA network in South Africa is already wellestablished, and encompasses considerable reef areas, being preferable for poenskop habitation. Conventional dart tagging and recapture information from three ongoing, long-term fishtagging projects, conducted throughout the poenskop’s distribution, indicated high levels of residency at all life-history stages. Coastal region, seasonality and time at recapture did not appear to have a significant effect on the level of movement or distance moved. However, on examining the relationship among coastal movements and fish size and ages, larger and older fish (adults) moved greater distances, with juveniles and sub-adults showing high degrees of residency. An estimation of home-range size indicated smaller poenskop to hold smaller home-ranges, while larger poenskop hold larger home-ranges. Large easterly displacements of a number of adult poenskop is in accordance with previous findings that this species may undertake a unidirectional migration up the coastline of South Africa where they possibly settle in Transkei waters for the remainder of their lives. This high level of residency makes poenskop vulnerable to localised depletion, although they can be effectively protected by suitable MPAs. Despite considerable tagging effort along the South African coastline (2 704 poenskop tagged with 189 recaptures, between 1984 and 2010), there remains limited information on the connectivity of different regions along the South African coastline. This was addressed using mitochondrial DNA sequencing. The mitochondrial DNA control region was used due to its high substitution rate, haploid nature, maternal inheritance and absence of recombination. The mtDNA sequencing showed no evidence of major geographic barriers to gene flow in this species. Samples collected throughout the core distribution of poenskop showed high genetic diversity (h = 0.88, π = 0.01), low genetic differentiation among regions, no spatial structure (ɸST = 0.012, p = 0.208) and no evidence of isolation by distance. The collapsed stock status of poenskop as well as the fact that it is being actively targeted by recreational and commercial fishers suggests that this species requires improved management, with consideration given to its life-history style, residency and poor conservation status. Management recommendations for poenskop, combined with increasing South Africa’s existing MPA network, include the possibility of setting up a closed season (during known spawning periods) as well as the decommercialisation of this species. The techniques used and developed in this study can also be adopted for other overexploited linefish species.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2013
Movement bahaviour of three South African inshore sparid species in rocky intertidal and shallow subtidal habitats
- Authors: Watt-Pringle, Peter Andrew
- Date: 2009
- Subjects: Sparidae -- South Africa , Diplodus , Sparodon Durbanensis , Fisheries -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5302 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005147 , Sparidae -- South Africa , Diplodus , Sparodon Durbanensis , Fisheries -- South Africa
- Description: This study investigated the movement behaviour of three inshore South African sparids – blacktail (Diplodus sargus capensis), zebra (Diplodus cervinus hottentotus) and white musselcracker (Sparodon durbanensis), popular inshore fishery species caught in appreciable numbers along much of the South African coast. The first study component examined movements of juveniles in a rocky intertidal nursery area at Schoenmakerskop near Port Elizabeth. Juveniles in a single gully were tagged with Visible Implant Elastomer (VIE) and resighted at the study site on snorkelling gear over a seven-month period. Tagged zebra and musselcracker displayed limited movement between potential low tide refuges, being observed repeatedly in the same gully over the full duration of the study. However, blacktail displayed greater movements and were seen infrequently in the later period of the study, probably having undergone an ontogenetic habitat shift to subtidal areas. There was evidence that blacktail maintain use of their intertidal nursery over high tide, during which the other two species moved into shallower areas adjacent to their low tide refuge. The results of three national tagging programs were analysed to determine the movement patterns of adolescent and adult fishes. The coast-wide ORI-WWF National Voluntary Tagging Program and two dedicated research programs in marine protected areas (MPAs) at De Hoop MPA and Tsitsikamma National Park (TNP) recorded few large-scale movements of tagged adult blacktail, zebra and juvenile musselcracker. High spatial-resolution data from the TNP suggested movements were usually on scales far smaller than one km. Together with long periods at liberty for many recaptured individuals, this suggests these fishes are longterm residents of small home range areas. However, tagged musselcracker over 600 mm forklength (adults) were observed to make large-scale movements, including some in excess of 800 km from Eastern Cape to KwaZulu-Natal waters. Predominantly eastward movements of adults recaptured during the spawning season indicate seasonal spawning migrations that occur in different regions of the coast. These enable the use of prevailing oceanographic currents to disperse eggs and larvae to suitable rocky nursery habitat. The third component of this study made use of high-resolution data on the temporal and spatial distribution of catches by scientific angling in the TNP to examine the daily activity patterns of the study species in relation to diel and tidal cycles, and habitat use. Blacktail capture probability was correlated with the diurnal light cycle, with peaks close to twilight suggesting elevated crepuscular foraging activity. Catches of blacktail, zebra and small musselcracker were correlated with the tidal cycle, foraging peaking over high tide periods. All three species used shallow inshore habitats extensively for foraging, blacktail showing a preference for sandy areas, while zebra and small musselcracker preferred shallow reef. Capture probability of larger musselcracker, however, was unrelated to habitat, possibly evidence of increasing area and habitat use with an ontogenetic change in diet. The lifetime movement patterns of these three species are discussed in relation to conservation measures and their management in South African fisheries. Restricted movement throughout post-settlement life for blacktail and zebra, and during the juvenile phase for musselcracker, makes local populations vulnerable to overexploitation. At present, MPAs probably play an important role in protecting local blacktail and zebra populations from overexploitation, and limited post-settlement movements mean the degree of larval dispersal between protected and adjacent areas will likely determine the effectiveness of MPAs in enhancing fisheries for these species. By contrast, MPAs likely provide recruits to fisheries for musselcracker during ontogenetic movements and dispersal from MPAs during spawning migrations. MPAs only offer partial protection to adult musselcracker populations in the spawning season, but this could nevertheless be significant under high levels of exploitation.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2009